The New Physician shieldThe New PhysicianThe work of Sonny Saggar, MD
Medicolegal

Clinical judgment for cases buried in medical records.

A chart documents what was written. A case turns on what actually happened. After roughly twenty-five years in emergency medicine, I read records the way they were created: under pressure, with incomplete information, by people making judgment calls in real time.

For Law Firms & Attorneys

What happened, and what mattered

Attorneys often receive thousands of pages of clinical material and still need answers to the fundamental questions: what was known at the time, what was foreseeable, what is hindsight, what caused the outcome, what evidence is missing, and what questions a retained expert should be made to answer.

The analysis is the same for plaintiff and defense counsel alike: what the clinical facts will actually support.

Possible assistance

  • · Medical record review
  • · Clinical chronology
  • · Identifying medically important facts
  • · Emergency medicine issues
  • · Medical literature review
  • · Documentation questions
  • · Clinical-record organization
  • · Documentation analysis
  • · Case screening
  • · Expert strategy
  • · Identifying questions for retained experts
  • · Deposition or trial-preparation consulting where appropriate
For Self-Represented Litigants

Understanding your own medical record

If you are representing yourself in a matter that involves medical records, the hardest part is often not the law. It is understanding what the medical record actually says, what it leaves out, and which clinical questions matter.

I can help you make sense of the medicine: the terminology, the timeline, how the documentation fits together, and which factual questions deserve investigation. I do not act as your lawyer, and I do not give legal advice.

Possible assistance

  • · Helping understand medical records
  • · Explaining medical terminology
  • · Organizing medical timelines
  • · Identifying clinical questions
  • · Finding relevant medical literature
  • · Understanding how medical documentation fits together
  • · Identifying factual inconsistencies in records
  • · Formulating questions to investigate
  • · Educational discussion of healthcare systems and clinical practice
Please note: Sonny Saggar is not acting as legal counsel. Services for self-represented litigants are limited to medical, factual, research, organizational, and educational assistance and do not constitute legal representation or legal advice.
Engagement & Fees

Typical engagement structures for retained medicolegal work:

  • Document review & consultation From $350 / hr
  • Expert declarations (Rule 26) From $3,500
  • Retained monthly advisory From $5,000 / mo
  • CLE presentations & seminars From $2,500

Scope and fee are agreed in writing before substantive work begins. All engagements are executed through Hive Advisory, a DBA of Universal Document Inc.

Related

Connected work

Research

The intent-standard and enforcement papers, including Knowingly and Willfully and When Intent Disappears, examine how clinical conduct is judged after the fact.

Research →

Mitigation & sentencing

Pre-sentencing clinical evaluation and supervised-release consulting remain a distinct advisory service.

Mitigation & sentencing →

The Road

A published, plain-language guide through the criminal process for the people inside it and the families beside them.

About the book →

Have a medical matter to evaluate?

Describe the matter in general terms, with no records and no protected health information, and I will tell you honestly whether a closer look is worth your while.

Discuss a Medical Matter

Information on this page is general in nature and does not create an attorney-client, physician-patient, or consulting relationship. Engagements are accepted only through a separate written agreement after conflict and suitability review.

How the work is framed

Problem: a large record set, a disputed sequence of events, or medical terminology that needs factual organization.

Method: records and literature review, chronology preparation, documentation analysis, and identification of questions or inconsistencies for the licensed professionals responsible for regulated decisions.

Work product: an organized chronology, records/evidence summary, question list, or independent research report, as agreed in writing.

Scope: this work does not include legal representation, legal advice, medical diagnosis or treatment, or an opinion on legal rights, standard of care, or causation.

Discuss a Problem →